NJCAA Division III All-Americans
| Name | Sport | All-America Team | Year |
| Shi'Miria Phillips | Volleyball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 2024 |
| Jakob Zenon | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2024 |
| Lia Santiago | Women's Soccer | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2023 |
| Love Riley | Volleyball | NJCAA DIII Second Team | 2023 |
| Darion Jones | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII Second Team | 2022-23 |
| Greg Crawford | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2021-22 |
| Braeson Barrs-Richardson | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII Honorable Mention | 2021-22 |
| Madison Hand | Volleyball | NJCAA DIII Second Team | 2019 |
| Tyler Stacy | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Second Team | 2019 |
| Dillon Eatman | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 2019 |
| Darek Brazeal | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2016-17 |
| Lanny Zier | Baseball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2012 |
| Patricia Del Valle | Women's Soccer | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2010 |
| Nicole McBrayer | Volleyball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2009 |
| Clint Dunham | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Second Team | 2008 |
| Megan Chetwood | Volleyball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2008 |
| Chris Agwumaro | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2005-06 |
| Kenneth Cage | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII Honorable Mention | 2004-05 |
| Kenneth Cage | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII Honorable Mention | 2003-04 |
| Jermaine Smith | Men's Basketball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 2002-03 |
| Jimmy Smith | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 2000 |
| Dan Miceli | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 1998 |
| Dean Smith | Baseball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 1995 |
| Jeff Landers | Baseball | NJCAA DIII First Team | 1994 |
| Brian Wolfe | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 1994 |
| Josh Prince | Baseball | NJCAA DIII Third Team | 1994 |